This review has been provided to British Army Review.
Author: William McCants
ISBN: 978-1-250-08090-5
Publisher: St Martin’s Press
Year: 2015
Hardcover
Pages: 242
Photos/Maps: 0
The War on Terror has prompted the drafting of hundred’s of
books covering all facets of the cause and personalities surrounding ISIS,
Al-Qaeda, the Taliban etc; however, one area that has received little to no ‘accessible
– to the layman’ interpretation has been a religious analysis of the driving
doctrine behind the various groups. McCant’s book covers the background and
history of ISIS but he also pays a significant amount of attention to the
Islamic canon, drawing upon his expertise in Islamic religious studies (he has
a PhD in Near Eastern Studies and speaks and reads Arabic fluently).
Islam as a religion is an extremely complex and confusing
faith; subject to interpretation by scholars going back hundreds of years. As
McCants points out if you want to find text promoting peaceful co-existence you
will find it just as you will find text advocating violent extremism against
non-believers. The author’s primary strength lies in his ability to quote
primary-source Arabic text to assist in his explanation of this to the layman.
Further, his talent at presenting this text within the context of the greater
narrative in such a way as to facilitate easy interpretation lends both
credence and accessibility to his account.
The challenge of dealing with the myriad of organizations
that make up the adversaries in the War on Terror, is exacerbated by the underlying motivators
that drive them and set the tone for their conduct and goals. Thus it is that
the extremists are not a homogeneous organization but deeply fractured and, as often
as not, fighting one another rather than secular forces. McCants goes to great
lengths in explaining this and underlying the fact that the goals and methods
of ISIS are neither condoned nor in common with those of Al-Qaeda and Bin
Laden. This is critical to understand because the West tends to lump these
organizations together in error as their means and methods are fundamentally
different.
He also goes on to explain how the population of the Middle
East’s perspective on the war has changed over the course of the conflict. Many
secular Muslims who initially viewed the war in terms of power politics have now
come to see the conflict in terms of the religious interpretation of the
Islamic “End Times” prophecy. The significant upheavals of the last decade
combined with the deep divide between Shia and Sunni as well as the ongoing
role of the “New Crusaders” have heralded, for many, the coming apocalypse.
This message resonates with the international Muslim community as well as
locals due the violence and tyranny in the very regions prophesized in the
Muslim texts.
McCants book fills a void missing in many of the narratives
on ISIS and its rise: that of the religious underpinnings justifying its
actions and the connection this has with the local population. His book is reasoned
and balanced. His deep understanding of Islam combined with his third person
perspective make for a book well worth the time to read and ponder.
No comments:
Post a Comment